The Last Interview with Łódź Kaliska
The Łódź Kaliska group in conversation with Krzysztof Cichoń and Andrzej Walczak
Appearing for Łódź Kaliska: Andrzej Świetlik as Świetlik, Andrzej Wielogórski as Makary, Marek Janiak as Janiak, and occasionally a chorus; for Atlas Sztuki: Andrzej Walczak as A.W. and Krzysztof Cichoń as K.C.; unidentified voices from time to time; on her own behalf: the Waitress.
Prologue
Unidentified Voice I: Let’s do it the traditional way: I’ll write the whole interview and be done with it.
Unidentified Voice II: Artists don’t read anyway…
Janiak: They used to do interviews like that with Warhol. At first a fellow wrote the questions, Warhol answered them and the fellow corrected him. Later, because Warhol had no time, the chronicler wrote both the questions and the answers, while Warhol merely checked them. In the final stage, he did not even check them any more. I have a book called Interviews with Andy Warhol. Brilliant.
Unidentified Voice II: The normal course of events in interpersonal communication. Spatial situations probably come about in much the same way. Someone always appears and says: oh no, we have to correct this, improve that, standardise it, make it communicate, bring the whole thing under control…
Janiak: And that is when disaster strikes.
Unrecognised Voice I: Let’s call it tragedy.
Act I, Scene I
(A very wide shot—as always—with no tarting up whatsoever. A Łódź salon. Everyone drinks tea incognito at a table. Nearer the door are several young people and two old Poles.)
Andrzej Świetlik (on the telephone): Where? On television? I think you should come here… Forget that lot and come over.
Andrzej Walczak: I hear you have some sort of exhibition proposal?
Krzysztof Cichoń: Łódź Kaliska makes proposals for planned exhibitions?
Świetlik: Usually Łódź Kaliska was invited. We never found ourselves wanting to stage an exhibition somewhere and having to submit a proposal for it.
A.W.: And now you have one?
Świetlik: Here you are. This is one quarter of the image that is to fill an entire wall in one of the rooms at Atlas Sztuki.
K.C.: It looks like a map, or one of the final boards on the last level of a shooting game, heavily depleted.
A.W.: After the apocalypse. Look how many outlines and traces of buildings there are. It looks more like a photograph of ancient ruins. There must once have been some civilisation there.
Makary: It’s Łódź.
K.C.: Indeed, you can tell from the Orthodox church.
A.W.: This is not a painting; it is a satellite photograph. Reality seen from above.
K.C.: ‘Reality seen from above’ in one room; and in the other?
Świetlik: Covered up. Here, this is one of the six objects we want to show there.
K.C.: Are these objects heavy?
Makary: Not particularly, but they should not be taken lightly.
Świetlik: And this will be the sound accompanying them.
A.W.: I recognise it: a recording straight out of ‘The Promised Land’.
K.C.: You gentlemen want to erect some sort of monument. Covering things like this nevertheless marks them out and evokes a shroud.
A.W.: It is a claim to exclusive possession of those objects. But no one ever covered worn-out, dusty machines. For me, that is the essence of the artistic gesture.
Świetlik: This kind of cloth is called a dust cover.
A.W.: It was called silk or cotton burette. An unfinished fabric.
K.C.: Echte Lodzermensch…
Świetlik: Objects used to be covered during a long absence. A very long one too. And that is the situation here.
A.W.: Has someone died, then? The city?
Świetlik: This exhibition addresses that problem.
K.C.: It is a monumental exhibition, if only because of those white shrouds. Culture is full of traces that encourage vaguely funereal associations of that kind.
Świetlik: I would not use the word ‘shroud’. It is better to keep to associations with dust covers used while one is away.
K.C.: Let’s call it a dust shroud, then.
A.W.: They are simply mummies.
Makary: Mummies lie down; machines stand.
Świetlik: Yes, these are standing machines. Machines that have stopped.
A.W.: But they are supposed to be trembling machines.
Makary: Only symbolically. All of Łódź has stopped, like the machines.
K.C.: We will not escape the funereal and monumental associations, if only because of this sterile whiteness.
A.W.: Alabaster white.
Makary: But that was the colour of dust covers.
K.C.: A cover over a machine ought to have stains, traces of grease. Yet this is sterile. These are covers for corpses, or the ghosts of machines.
Świetlik: If you are leaving a car standing for a long time, you have to clean it. I clean mine before winter. Besides, we are working in fairly general terms. I do not think the idea requires details of this kind to be analysed. For me, such analyses are an interesting phenomenon in themselves.
A.W.: Today it would be covered with black or transparent plastic. No one would cover anything with white plastic.
K.C.: Łódź Kaliska has always scribbled on things, added words and drawings, filled in the gaps and so forth—especially in its museum-and-reminiscence period. Yet here we have immaculate whiteness with emptiness beneath it. I would call it a ‘contemplative’ composition. Will all six machines be ‘covered’ with fabric draped in the same way?
Świetlik: No, each with a different one.
K.C.: Will the folds be different?
Makary: Yes, however they happen to fall.
A.W.:Were you not guided by aestheticism when covering these machines?
Świetlik and Makary (in chorus): No!
A.W.: It seems to me that, unlike in many of your earlier activities, you nevertheless insisted that everything—every fold—be highly polished. I cannot recall you ever taking such care in your previous actions to avoid shoddy work.
Świetlik: Is that good or bad?
A. W.: It comes from respect.
K.C.: For the corpse?
Świetlik: For the machines, the standing machines.
K.C.: Futurism, or merely fussing over the folds?
Świetlik: You are suggesting that aesthetic considerations determined things, and that is not true.
Makary: The machines’ shape determines the folds. We simply covered them; we were not searching for picturesque drapery.
K.C.: Ah, picturesque folds in art history—that could be The Way to Paradise, as we know from Peter Cornell’s book.
Świetlik: Thinking about folds in terms of fifteenth-century paintings is a professional perversion.
K.C.: A professional photographer naturally pays no attention whatsoever to the arrangement of fabric within the frame.
A.W.: Your activities were always a long process, from conversations to rehearsals. The process of creation—in this case the arrangement of the folds—was important. I would simply like to know how long you spent arranging these fabrics.
Świetlik: When you throw a piece of fabric over anything…
Makary: Not anything: over a machine. The machine decided, its form.
Świetlik: Over a machine—you always adjust it involuntarily. You adjust it to cover everything, but that does not mean it is particularly important. Let’s not turn it into the essence of the work.
A.W.: But are you interested in what you covered? Its essence? Those machines do not exist, after all. Are you interested only in the superficial act of covering? Let us finally ask the gentlemen from Łódź Kaliska whether they have become precious little aesthetes.
Świetlik (graciously, to the passing Waitress): We are redirecting that question to you.
Waitress: Not now.
Świetlik (answering the telephone): Janiak suggests we wait for him before continuing this conversation.
K.C.: So what are we supposed to do?
Świetlik: Eat, drink and smoke our pipes.
A.W.: Let’s smoke our pipes!
K.C.: How loud is the sound meant to be?
Świetlik: It should be clearly audible—even irritating.
K.C.: But nineteenth-century sound was deafening.
A.W.: I witnessed the gentlemen disagreeing about the threshold of audibility. That may also have something to do with age.
Makary: My hearing is worse, so I turned it up the most.
K.C.: Apparently young people hear even worse.
Świetlik: I would not count on young people. There will be no naked women in this exhibition, so they may feel disappointed.
Makary: Don’t exaggerate.
K.C.:Young men.
Świetlik: If we do not reveal too much in advance, they will come expecting what they always get. And they will find themselves at an educational exhibition.
A.W.: With sound.
Makary: They will have a chance to test their hearing.
Świetlik: We could make one machine in the form of a woman.
Makary: Bear in mind that a machine is feminine.
K.C.: Feminists complain that it is the other way round.
A.W.: It is scandalous, this lack of scandal in your exhibition.
Scene II
(Everyone talks animatedly, in Polish.)
K.C.: Since we are discussing art history and textiles, who else could be placed beneath the same cover that encloses The Trembling Machines? Who used fabric in this way? Michelangelo Pistoletto threw little rags and whole piles of clothes over ancient sculptures, almost covering them. Magdalena Abakanowicz made plenty of textiles stiffened over something.
Makary: Those were people, not machines.
K.C.: And before that, those great cocoons—the Abakans. Can you guess what might have been inside?
K.C.: The corpse-pale horror of soulless art history—of academic, lifeless memory—lies in the way context evaporates over the years, leaving only a dusty, stiffened piece of dust-cover fabric. Form remains and is juxtaposed with similar forms and materials.
Makary: Christo covered quite a few things too.
K.C.: Indeed, and he also tended to choose covers in a single strong colour.
A.W.: You are not doing very well with art history. You are forcing it. Many people covered things all the time; museum storerooms are full of dusty wrappings. Yet Łódź Kaliska has covered something only once before. They are better known for uncovering things.
K.C.: Excuse me, but apparently you once threw something over someone without warning, in a street in Darłowo, for no apparent reason…
Makary and Świetlik (in chorus): To smack arses!
K.C.: It is frightening to attend the opening if they still remember. They will start with the machines, and we know how it will end…
Scene III
A.W.: It seems to me that your activities always arose from some crisis, from a refusal to accept the situation.
Świetlik: For me, the cause of the crisis is Janiak’s absence.
Makary: That is not the point…
Świetlik: I do not mean the here and now. We meet to do things for Łódź Kaliska—even in the afternoons—and he has gone off to take office.
K.C.: As a naïve viewer, I wanted to ask a question. Is this an exhibition by Łódź Kaliska, or an exhibition by the City Architect of Łódź?
Świetlik: My dear sir, you are not a naïve viewer.
K.C.: Has Łódź Kaliska become an annex to the problems of the city architect, in a city that is apparently not doing terribly well?
Makary: This project was conceived before Marek Janiak took office.
Świetlik: We are a little worried about that. Marek is very worried about it.
A.W.: You always tried to find positive, even joyful ways of dealing with a crisis. This exhibition is not exactly joyful, is it?
Świetlik: I disagree. Look how beautiful those little folds are.
K.C.: Łódź Kaliska came into being as a result of a crisis. If they had not thrown you out of that plein-air workshop in 1979, you would not exist.
Makary: That is true.
(Marek Janiak enters)
Janiak: Good morning!
K.C.: Now a crisis is guaranteed.
A.W.: I wanted to ask at once: how will it end? What will the ending be?
Janiak: The end of what? The world? The city?
A.W.: The end of Łódź Kaliska. The city is more important, though!
Makary: You baited him.
A.W.: We are discussing yet another crisis in Łódź Kaliska.
Janiak: Excuse me, but would it not be better—and more topical—to discuss the crisis at Łódź Fabryczna?
K.C.: Could you manage to cover that with something?
Makary: I think Christo would be needed for that.
Janiak: I think that is a brilliant idea. If we caused some gigantic crisis of everything—preferably of Europe, or better still the entire globe—it would be an impressive avant-garde action in the field of art.
K.C.: That is why I always wanted to stage an exhibition by Leszek Balcerowicz at Atlas Sztuki.
Janiak: I know nothing about economics, but I am more inclined to respect him than to believe those who criticise him.
K.C.: If I did not respect him, I would not propose an exhibition. Especially in the city of Łódź.
A.W.: What is the difference between a crisis of the state and a crisis of the city?
Janiak: A crisis of the state translates into a crisis of the cities within it. Every Polish crisis immediately affects Łódź, which is milked dry.
K.C.: We have reached the conclusion that this is an exhibition by the City Architect rather than by Łódź Kaliska.
Janiak: Excuse me, I have repeatedly stressed that the two have nothing to do with each other. The only connection is that, as an artist from the Łódź Kaliska circle who works together with his colleagues, I am also an admirer of Łódź as an urban structure. I mean its architectural and urban-planning structure, less its social one. That is why I was sympathetic to this exhibition, although I think that, as art, it is moving dangerously close to journalism. I always took care to make the level of generalisation visible, so that it would not merely be a journalistic exhibition about this city. Although that is largely what it is, one way or another.
K.C.: That may prove difficult. You will go out into the wider world—to Marseille, for instance, as you did recently—and at the entrance you will have to put up a school-club-style wall newspaper explaining that ‘Lodz’ is a city in the middle of Eastern Europe, full of trembling machines. As long as your art was not particularly keen on covering breasts, no such explanations were needed. A city and its anatomy are far more local than human anatomy.
Janiak: This is not a local problem, but a problem of this post-communist part of Europe. Countries that were not scarred by Bolshevism—with its distortion of every value system and its interruption of development for more than fifty years—are unable to understand where we now stand in terms of cultural consciousness.
A.W.: Even those that went through the French Revolution?
Janiak: Yes, because that revolution did not break the structures of continuity. Structures of power evolved fairly slowly there, whereas the Bolshevik Revolution cut everything down. But let us return to Łódź. Something monstrous happened. The city, which developed in the nineteenth century at the same or even a faster pace than many European cities, raced ahead of its time. A gigantic city arose in fifty years, just as in the United States. Only Chicago developed at a comparable pace. Suddenly, somewhere at the end of the world, there was America. After the Second World War, it was condemned to death. The people who flowed into Łódź came not from another city, as in Wrocław, for example, but from the countryside; they did not understand the city and were afraid of it. Communist rhetoric kept telling them: this is a hideous capitalist city where children fall ill in tiny, bedbug-infested courtyards; we shall build beautiful housing estates. And they built cities of prefabricated concrete. Soulless, but with a kitchen and bathroom…
Świetlik: Did you already say that on television today?
Janiak: More or less. During the television discussion, one of the young directors said that Łódź had been shaped by capitalist exploitation. Rhetoric from the Gomułka and Gierek eras—I could not believe it! A man says this in 2013, when most of Paris, Barcelona, Vienna and other normal European cities were shaped in exactly the same way.
A.W.: As city architect, you will build us a wondrous city.
Janiak: I do not want to build any wondrous city. I want this city not to fall apart or perish. It is the squandering of what earlier generations achieved…
Świetlik: I am moved…
Janiak: And that is what this exhibition is about. About passing away; about the stupidity of destroying what one received for free. About disrespecting other people’s achievements, about nonchalance, pettiness and social squalor that destroys everything systematically!
K.C.: Your emotion is catching. Łódź Kaliska, accused for years of hooliganism and contempt for social norms, is defending values.
Janiak: We have always defended values! Sincerity, honesty, acting in accordance with one’s own conscience. We kicked social hypocrisy and hypocrisy in the art world. That is why they came to dislike us. We said: you are liars, you are bloody useless and you have no talent! We always defended freedom and creativity, and now we are talking about the same things.
SCENE IV
K.C.: Gentlemen, I propose a little sideways leap. Let us take a break from this city for a moment. In which direction shall we go from your canvases draped over trembling machines? Towards Mickiewicz, or towards hooliganism?
Makary: Towards Mickiewicz; more trams run that way…
Janiak: Towards hooliganism? There is no such theme in these canvases.
K.C.: It seems to me that a true bard can be a hooligan, and sometimes vice versa…
Janiak: I do not think so. I have seen hooligans at football grounds, and I doubt they were prophesying anything.
K.C.: Refe-ren-dum!
Janiak: Mickiewicz was a nutter, really. I like some of the stunts he pulled. He lived life to the full.
K.C.: It seems that you gentlemen still have a long-standing secondary-school problem from the 1960s. In many of your manifestos, proclamations and odes you keep lashing out at nineteenth-century literature as though it had inflicted a painful injury upon you. At the same time, some of you declare your admiration for the architecture of that period.
Świetlik: We mean the first half of the nineteenth century.
K.C.: Perhaps the second half as well, to some extent.
Janiak: Not at all. The second half was creative. Creative capitalism. The first was dreary Romanticism!
K.C.: You write in your proclamations: ‘How appealing it is not to give a damn about Mickiewicz and Słowacki.’ Could you elaborate on why it is so appealing, all these years after your final school exams? What do you have against Romanticism? Especially now, when you are prettifying a thousand white folds, underpinned by a powerful sound, with emptiness beneath. Contemplation of a collapsing city in billowing bloom! Since we are not drinking, let us read poetry. Permit me a short passage; you will be moved again:
‘To pursue thoughts through images past,
Wandering like a parasitic herb,
Which across the stones of an ancient edifice
Strews its scattered branches.’
That is the ending of Mickiewicz’s ‘The Phantom’, but when I look at the map you gentlemen have doctored, I am indeed looking at ‘images past of stones from an ancient edifice’. And the little folds you have draped tremble gently like the herb.
Janiak: Calf! Calf—which means it is about the countryside, and we are not interested in the countryside, only the city.
A.W.: I think we have already discussed the threshold of audibility today…
Makary: It is harder to hear in the city.
Świetlik: We also said that the little folds do not interest us.
K.C.: If only because of the appearance of these six covers over trembling machines, this is a Romantic exhibition.
Janiak: I disagree. This exhibition is conceptual and logical, not Romantic. Romanticism was emotional.
Świetlik: And hysterical.
Janiak: Is there a Świtezianka or a Wernyhora anywhere in this exhibition?
K.C.: Those white covers are not far removed from trembling ghosts. The exhibition is funereal, a little mournful, aestheticising—simply pretty. This will be a new period for Łódź Kaliska, because it cannot possibly fit within New Pop. Where is the energy, where is the action? It must be either major or minor.
Janiak: A good artist can manage eight octaves.
K.C.: But either cheerfully or sadly.
A.W.: Even so, the exhibition smells of a cemetery. As a tribute, you will receive flowers at the opening…
Janiak: Oh, surely not. Who would give us flowers?
Świetlik: Little girls in white.
K.C.: And Wernyhora will appear instead of the rustic Chochoł. At the end of the text accompanying the exhibition, Łódź Kaliska and Marek Janiak write that the exhibition is a story about ‘social boorishness; about the collective boor who loses the golden horn and does not even notice; about a race against time being lost by a city devoured by nonchalance and neglect; a story about children who destroy their parents’ achievements instead of adding to them…’ Moving….
Janiak: I would like to point out that this is not Romantic…
A.W.: Because it does not rhyme.
Janiak: It is Positivist.
A. W.: It looks like a quatrain.
Makary: Like a quart. It is a new, short form; we are working on it.
K.C.: ‘The Trembling Machines is a story of departing without returning.’
Świetlik: Maria Konopnicka?
K.C.: Also an M, but it is Marek Janiak and Łódź Kaliska.
A.W.: Could we bind this conversation together with the word Łódź? You added Kaliska, but this exhibition is quite important to me because it concerns Łódź.
K.C.: And after the break…
Janiak: You know, we are from Łódź. Andrzej Świetlik still comes here because he is from Warsaw…
Świetlik: I am from Złoczów.
Janiak: And the motherland spoke within us—but since we are men, please write ‘fatherland’.
A.W.: This exhibition is very Łódź, very moving. We are proud that the city architect…
Janiak: Once again I should like to mention that the coincidence between my being city architect and this exhibition is unintended. The exhibition was conceived before I became an official.
A.W.: You never felt the need to become an official.
Janiak: I did not. I did, however, feel the need to make this exhibition, albeit rather faintly. Andrzej pushed hardest for it. It happened because of Świetlik; Rzepa from Kraków supported him, while I was in the minority.
K.C.: And if you were making an exhibition like this about Kraków, what would be covered? Surely not machines. Royal tombs?
Świetlik: Rzepa.
Janiak: Perhaps Skrzynecki.
A. W.: One of the unquestionably greater poets of Łódź was Rajmund Rembieliński. I take it that, for you, Rembieliński is…
Świetlik: The name of a street…
Janiak: No, Rembieliński was a terrific fellow. He did a great deal for Łódź.
A.W.: As a poet?
Janiak: No, as an official.
K.C.: An official who did a great deal for Łódź! The Romantics could not have invented anything better. This thread is becoming so absurd that we had better cut it short.
PART III
SCENE II
(after a long silence)
Janiak: At first there were aerial photographs of the sites of demolished factory complexes. Once we had conceived the fabrics covering absent machines, we decided that isolated fragments with demolished factories—treated, as Świetlik wished, in purely aesthetic terms—did not convey the scale of the problem. The idea then emerged of showing a large section of central Łódź in the form it will take in the exhibition.
Unidentified Voice: Is that done in Photoshop?
Janiak: It depends what we mean. If we mean our orthophotomap, with its apocalyptic vision of the destination towards which the society of this city is heading, then it is done in Photoshop. It is now very easy to make something disappear from or appear in a photograph. This is not a vision of just any city. It is a slightly sharpened depiction of the attitude that the citizens of this city have towards themselves. That is their system of values. If everything ceased to exist, most of them would not be particularly moved. This defines the consciousness of Łódź’s residents, their attitude towards the historic urban fabric.
Unidentified Voice: I am moved by your faith, Professor, that the shape of a city depends on the consciousness of its inhabitants.
Janiak: To an enormous extent, yes.
Unidentified Voice: As a serving official, you should know that the connection is not so direct. Decision-making mechanisms are largely detached from the consciousness of residents.
Janiak: I disagree completely.
Unidentified Voice: Does the will of the people shape cities?
Janiak: I believe that the ultimate source is nothing but the consciousness of the inhabitants. First, as the public voice in a democracy, they could influence decisions and what happens. Second, some of them take part in these processes. They include people who bought factories and demolished them. Third, the political and intellectual elites that make decisions come from this society. Their consciousness is the same as the nation’s. That is why the consciousness of a nation shapes cities. Apart from honourable exceptions, I would say that these elites are not especially interested in enriching their consciousness or learning. Very often they remain wedded to their views. Besides, very little is done to educate society. That has been the most important field, at least since 1990. It is done to a minimal extent, if at all. This also applies to the press and other media. We know the standard of journalism: more sensation than education.
Unidentified Voice: Łódź Kaliska spent a long time considering the problem: culture or nature? Personally, which would you bet on?
Janiak: I believe nature is the cause of culture. Certain cultural phenomena arise from atavisms, especially in politics and wherever rivalry is involved. Human beings possess personality traits that result from evolution.
Unidentified Voice: I ask because I do not understand why you want to show this particular, uninteresting moment in the city’s history. Perhaps you should have used Photoshop to show how idyllic the city centre will look in two hundred years, when the Łódź Forest grows green here once again.
Janiak: I understand the mischievousness of the question…
Unidentified Voice: It is not about mischievousness, but inevitability. Some processes may be impossible to stop.
Janiak: It is absolutely mischievous. All our intuitions and research indicate that the number of people on Earth is growing ever faster and that the environment is being degraded. Energy efficiency in appropriating the environment demands considerable discipline in urban planning—concentration, rather. The greater the density, the better the chances of structures, and indeed the species itself, surviving. This applies both in the longer term, when we wonder whether humanity will survive, and in the shorter term, when we ask whether certain structures will remain economically viable or turn into the torment of crisis, widespread hunger or an even worse calamity. We now know that we must behave sensibly. Theories of sustainable development say that we must stop devouring and begin using what already exists, behaving more economically. In relation to urbanisation, this means that cities will defend themselves as the most densely concentrated structures. From the point of view of social and energy security, they will probably be the places with the greatest chance of survival. When a herd huddles together, only part of it dies of cold; when it disperses, the whole herd dies.
Unidentified Voice: The problem is that, as a species, we are guided by at least one more factor when deciding whether to huddle together. Admittedly, one freezes more slowly in a herd, but the stench inside is almost unbearable.
Janiak: It is a choice between dying in the fresh air and fighting the stench while nevertheless surviving. I think another atavism—the desire to survive—will simply decide to switch off the olfactory receptors.
Unidentified Voice: That is certainly an optimistic choice awaiting us.
Janiak: In this mischievous construction, you inadvertently touched upon something important. If the people of Łódź continue to behave selfishly and somewhat irresponsibly, they will begin to annihilate themselves. That is already happening. The city may lose its race against time, and the vision in that gloomy photograph may come true. Society will then face a colossal problem: whether to move away and let the jungle engulf everything, or accept the permanent risk of living within a semi-wild structure. Signals of this are already coming from Detroit, for example, where certain parts of the city no longer function because wilderness reigns there. That is a wealthy society, whereas ours is poor. Here, wilderness will fill everything more quickly and will certainly be more chaotic.
Unidentified Voice: Do you not think that you are fighting on the side of those who say: keep it alive, keep it going; it may be unconscious now, but perhaps consciousness will return one day? The economic reasons that shaped this city no longer exist. It has no economic raison d’être, yet let us preserve its form. Is that rational, or does it arise from an atavistic fear of change? One must have profound faith that life will return and sustain itself here naturally, without continual resuscitation.
Janiak: That is flawed rhetoric. The immediate reasons for the city’s creation have disappeared, but other reasons have taken their place. It is not as though a complete void appeared. The urban organism no longer survives, as it once did, solely because of industry. Other reasons are sufficient today.
Unidentified Voice: The life of such large cities today—their scale, location or rather position—resembles the teeming processes of decay within a great fallen log. Life goes on, while simultaneously eating away at the city’s fabric. In Łódź, the rot begins at crossroads; more and more of them have buildings on only one or two corners.
Janiak: If that were really the case, the pathologisation and death of the city would be far more advanced than they are. It is not my place to assess and study such socio-economic relationships. I do not think things can be that bleak, because much of it is still doing reasonably well. At one point, light industry moved into small workshops and continued to produce a great deal. The goods reached Russia through Tuszyn. Admittedly, that has ended too. Few people know it, but there are still powerful companies here producing yarn that is shipped to China. It is certainly untrue that all life-giving juices have drained away. It is difficult to say how much remains and whether the arteries and veins can widen or will wither, but we are at a different moment. Comparing it with history is of little use and contributes nothing. The reasons for which the city arose and the communities that built it do not matter to me, because those communities no longer exist. Nor do those reasons. Dwelling on it is pointless. The city exists. We were given it for free. It is an enormous asset, the product of a vast amount of energy invested in creating all this. It is a product that exists. The whole art lies in not squandering it. Squandering it would be an act of monumental stupidity, and I hate stupidity. I am not fighting because some mission to save something according to an established hierarchy of values has inspired me. Stupidity simply infuriates me: stupidity that wastes energy, destroys beautiful things and makes life meaningless. I seriously ask myself how this race against time will end. Will this society manage to save what forms the basis of its existence here? Or will it continue behaving as it has until, two hundred years from now, future generations of historians sit down and say: it is unimaginable what a stupid nation must have lived here to bring this about. I fear such an ending.
Unidentified Voice: I want to ask about an obvious contradiction. Contradictions in a work of art are fascinating and worth picking at. What you are showing appeals to reason. The height of this reason is supposed to consist not in building anew, but above all in using what already exists. Yet your orthophotomap owes its apocalyptic appearance to showing a centre to which nobody has added anything.
Janiak: You have now revealed your ignorance of urban planning and architecture. Using what already exists means not only using the buildings themselves, but also making intelligent use of the spaces between them—the road layout and utilities. If there had been more of these things in the centre after 1945, that would have meant sensible use and development of what already existed. In many parts of its centre, this city was—and is now all the more, because it is falling apart—an unfinished city. The mistake made in the 1960s was not to complete the structure of the centre, but instead to begin building separate cities—prefabricated concrete housing estates—far away from it. If we saw such a map of the entire city, it would look like this: an empty centre and masses of new estates on the outskirts.
Unidentified Voice: That is what colonies of bacteria on laboratory dishes look like from above: spreading from the centre outwards.
Janiak: I think bacterial colonies are guided by something different from human communities.
Unidentified Voice: I think that, besides access to nutrients, they are guided by optimising energy use, among other things. It is simply easier that way.
Janiak: Yes, it was easier that way.
Unidentified Voice: The power of this map lies in showing vast areas of emptiness in the centre. It turns out that three generations of residents have left no material trace there.
Janiak: Or only a pitiful one. Investment in the centre began only when people believed it could be transformed along socialist lines by building a central housing estate, but that failed. They miscalculated.
Unidentified Voice: Perhaps Łódź is East Germany in miniature. Entire countries are collapsing despite the colossal resources channelled into reviving them. People simply do not live there, perhaps because they lack access to nutrients.
Janiak: When I compare Łódź with other cities, it has a better structure. It is more compact. Through historical accident and development, it has factory complexes in its centre that can readily assume other functions, becoming offices, cultural centres, shopping centres or car parks. That does not force the structure outwards. There is no dilemma about whether to build a new centre in a former mine ten kilometres from the old one, or whether people will travel there. Everything can be in the centre. We are enormously fortunate. Yet in some extraordinary way Łódź cannot capitalise on this, and that is terrible.
Unidentified Voice: Let us talk about art, because in a moment it will be difficult to convince anyone that this is not an exhibition by the City Architect. So much is happening now, after all. Have you noticed anything in art worth remembering? Any young artists?
Janiak: I do not feel anyone breathing down my neck. That frightens me a little. The younger generation has made no serious proposal. Most often, it merely reprocesses everything—forcing open doors that have long stood open. And what came before is presented in such a way that young people do not even want to explore it.
Unidentified Voice: Just as you do not feel like reading the Romantics. That is probably normal.
Janiak: I did read those Romantics once, though. The tragedy is that the youngest generations have fallen asleep. The relative prosperity that has emerged in comparison with the communist era is not yet great enough to produce a revolt against prosperity.
Unidentified Voice: As children of crisis, you angrily demanded bigger tits for less money, while they simply have them. A blessed situation, though for some reason not a very appealing one.
Janiak: I also encounter young people at university, and I am somewhat alarmed there too. Those who feel the need to create meaning in their lives out of everything around them have never been a majority…
Unidentified Voice: One always speaks to a handful of people, regardless of the size of the room.
Janiak: Yes, but today I cannot see even that handful.
Unidentified Voice: Because your eyesight is not what it was. Let us talk about art; students are a subject almost like the city—not worth getting involved in. Back in the 1980s, in various attics cut off from the ‘real world’, people collectively practised dreary Romanticism.
Janiak: Excuse me, it was thoroughly cheerful Pop Art, not Romanticism.
Unidentified Voice: It seemed important to those who took part in that life, and from time to time it assumed a memorable form. Now we are part of the great, cheerful art market—and what of it? Please name at least two people worth remembering. In a moment it will turn out that when it comes down to it, the professor drones on terribly and pessimistically.
Janiak: Where does that come from?
Unidentified Voice: Perhaps a situation of oppression, isolation and the absence of bigger tits for less money is conducive after all…
Janiak: Do you think Romantic misery is the driving force of art? Some kind of pressure? At that time, art was a genuine realm of freedom for small groups. Even the communist regime permitted freedom to exist there. Of course, whenever it began to expand, the regime suppressed it. Political struggle is no longer freedom. Now we supposedly have ubiquitous freedom, which is no freedom at all, but corporate and economic oppression. It has an extraordinarily insidious feature to which the younger generation succumbs: this oppression completely satisfies the hunger for small needs and small happiness. One can travel, buy things or watch them for free. The satisfaction of small needs enslaves people to such an extent that they forget their deeper needs, of which Romanticism always dreamt…
Unidentified Voice: and Łódź Kaliska too.
Janiak: They forget complete freedom. It is a very clever system. Perhaps small pleasures are enough. We satisfy our physiology up to our armpits, I would say, in ways physiologists never dreamt of. The situation is deceptive because it reduces people to consumers and producers of the simplest, childishly active needs. Nor are there any breathtaking propositions in world art. It is all shallow. When one looks at what the world of ambitious photography produces, seventy per cent of it is dreadful sociology that has used the same way of looking for thirty years: the same search for the lame, the old and the alienated. Nonsense. In my view, the most beautiful photography is that which grew out of Conceptualism. There is still beautiful commercial and fashion photography. It is close to the poetics of Pop Art and to the aesthetics of the product. Everything is specially cultivated, including the models. It is an optimistic world, and it is beautiful. Perhaps that is where the value of art should be sought. Perhaps art should not be sought in missions to expose threats and struggle; perhaps it has moved into the realm of satisfying consumption and now revolves around that. Perhaps Pop Art, in its affirmation of plastic, human-made beauty—at odds with the ancient and Renaissance model of divine, idealised beauty—proved more prophetic than we realise. Pop Art noticed the human being as a creature that likes to consume and knows how to organise consumption, for whom creating an artificial world is important. An ape cannot create an artificial world; a human being can. I believe there is plenty of good art, but not where we look for it. When the ministry funds art, it wastes money, because the ministry always supports art that whinges and suffers. Its funding should be taken away—let it die! Give it instead to art that is simply beautiful. I think we are looking for what matters in the wrong places.
Unidentified Voice: Does Łódź Kaliska have any premonition of or need for its own end?
Janiak: No. It puts one in a bad mood. I do not think anyone in Łódź Kaliska thinks about it. We are not contemplating a mausoleum. In fact, we have already made one by accident. There is the installation ‘Pure Art’ in the toilet at Muzeum Sztuki. It is a legally protected work of art. The museum is obliged to conserve it and reconstruct it should anything happen. So we already have a mausoleum. It is brilliant that it is in a toilet, in a palace. It is even slightly below ground, almost a crypt. It is fundamental art. In the Hermitage and the Louvre, the art that forms the foundation of everything that comes later is also in the basement. We are already there too.